Ruben van Eijk
Executive creative advisor
Formerly Chief Creative Officer at Slash.Digital and Head of Creative Shop CEE at Meta.
Define your objective well: create on hypothesis and scale on outcome.
Nineteen working ad makers, from a former Meta creative lead to a D&AD judge, vote for the three platforms they make ads with, and say why.
Issue 1 of this report asked eleven AI ad studios how they ship client work. This time we asked working ad makers a simpler question: when a brief lands, which platform do you open first, and which two come after it? Nineteen of them answered, from agency creative directors to founders of AI production studios, and each one told us why.
Magnific won the vote. Seven first-place votes, more than any other platform, and a place on nine of the nineteen ballots. Higgsfield sits on more ballots (ten) but mostly lower down. CapCut is third, almost always as the place where ads get finished. The table is only half the story, though. Ask these people why, and nearly all of them describe a toolkit, not a favourite.
VibeDex is an independent AI comparison engine. We benchmark the models ourselves and map what creative platforms can actually do. This report is the human half: what working ad makers choose when the work has to ship.
The short answer
For AI ad and UGC work in late 2026, the panel's #1 is Magnific (25 points, 7 first-place votes), then Higgsfield (21) and CapCut (13), with Adobe Firefly (9) and Runway (7) next. Count only the votes from people with no partner tie to the platform, and Higgsfield (18) and Magnific (17) are level at the top.
Why there are two columns
11 of the 19 have a creator, partner or ambassador relationship with at least one platform. So we count every vote, then count again with each person's votes for their own partner platforms removed. Both columns are below.
Magnific. The scoring is simple: 3 points for a #1, 2 for a #2, 1 for a #3. Magnific took 25 points from nine ballots, and seven of those nine put it first. Higgsfield appears on ten ballots but took three first-place votes, so it finishes second on 21.
| # | Platform | All votes (pts) | #1 votes | Ballots | Without partner votes (pts) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Magnific | 25 | 7 | 9 | 17 |
| 2 | Higgsfield | 21 | 3 | 10 | 18 |
| 3 | CapCut | 13 | 2 | 7 | 9 |
| 4 | Adobe Firefly | 9 | 1 | 5 | 9 |
| 5 | Runway | 7 | – | – | – |
| 6 | Krea | 6 | – | – | – |
| 7 | ImagineArt | 5 | – | – | – |
| 8 | Figma Weave | 5 | – | – | – |
19 ballots counted (a twentieth was received and is not included), 3/2/1 points. Platforms on fewer than five ballots show total points only. Eighteen platforms were named in total; the other ten shared the remaining points, none with more than 4.
Behind the top two the field spreads out fast. Eighteen platforms turn up across nineteen ballots, and only four of them (Magnific, Higgsfield, CapCut and Adobe Firefly) appear on more than a quarter.
Mostly, but the top becomes a tie. Creator programs are how many ad makers get credits and early access, so an honest panel includes program members. We count their votes, then count again without them.
Magnific drops eight points, because three of its voters disclosed a tie to it. Higgsfield drops three. That leaves Higgsfield on 18 and Magnific on 17, a single point apart. Adobe Firefly keeps every vote and CapCut drops four, so the rest of the order holds.
The most common answer was not a platform at all. One ad maker after another said there is no single best tool: every job, and sometimes every shot, needs a different one.
Range in one place
Magnific's supporters talk about access and finish: many video models under one roof, upscaling and detail enhancement, and an interface one voter called simply the best. Another put it more coolly: the best compromise in an ecosystem that is still very immature. Higgsfield's supporters talk about cinematic quality, camera movement and having the models together, and value it for quick social work.
Output that needs the least fixing
Some judge platforms on effort against output. Runway is praised for the highest quality with the least adjustment, and Adobe Firefly for high output on complex tasks once you have put in the training.
The pipeline you finish in
Firefly earns its votes from people who finish in Adobe: it sits inside the pipeline they deliver from, and it has made a strong comeback for high-end visual marketing. CapCut plays the same role for editing, transitions and final cuts.
Credits decide the switch
Several ad makers move between platforms to stretch their credits, and pick the cheaper route when the result is the same.
Not image quality. Every contributor told us what platforms need most, and the answers cluster around control.
Consistency across shots (9 of 19). The same character, face, product and scene from one shot to the next. For ad work this is the job: a product that changes shape between shots is unusable.
Control and editing (9 of 19). Camera control, precise edits, and the ability to change one thing without regenerating the rest. One contributor put it plainly: sometimes you just want to change one thing without the AI redesigning the entire universe.
Cost and transparency (5 of 19). Credits that are hard to predict, retries that still get billed, and limits and queue times that are not stated up front. Two also asked for clearer commercial usage terms, which matter more for ads than for almost any other kind of work.
Less generic output (2 of 19). Platforms built so that anyone gets the same ad. One lead creative asked for tools that push beyond what a single prompt gives everyone.
The same advice came back again and again: start with the idea, not the prompt.
Start with an idea, preferably a great one. Decide what the ad is for and how it relates to the brand before anything is generated.
Test one variable at low resolution before spending credits on a full run. Every experiment costs money.
Cut alongside generation to catch continuity errors early, and get fresh eyes on the work.
Define the objective, create on a hypothesis, and scale on the outcome.
Don't aim for something that looks AI-generated. Aim for something that feels authentic enough to sell.
Stop following trends and challenge clients, or the work ends up in an ocean of sameness.
The next ads edition publishes for Christmas. From now on every ballot also rates each of its three platforms on consistency and on value: how much finished, usable work you get for what you spend once retries and credits are counted. Separately, we are testing what it costs to change one thing in a finished ad on each video agent, because that is where the panel says the time and money go.
The Panel
All nineteen contributors are credited by name below, and all nineteen ballots are counted in every table. Full bios and featured work are in the appendix.
Executive creative advisor
Formerly Chief Creative Officer at Slash.Digital and Head of Creative Shop CEE at Meta.
Define your objective well: create on hypothesis and scale on outcome.
Chief Creative Officer, nmatic.ai
Previously Executive Creative Director at BBDO, DDB, Lowe and Interone China; four and a half years in generative AI.
Start with an idea. Preferably a fun idea. Better still a great idea.
AI Creative Lead, Highive
Former Creative Director at Sainsbury’s and D&AD Awards judge.
Plan well when doing AI video generation, because every experiment costs money.
AI Creative Director
Gen AI Creative Specialist at Publicis Groupe Spain, with two AI Design Awards 2025 special recognitions.
Don’t rely on AI to do all the creative thinking for you.
AI Lead & Senior Creative Producer, Grey Denmark (WPP)
AI Lead and Senior Creative Producer at Grey Denmark, part of WPP.
Understand what each model’s weaknesses and strengths are, so you can build the most efficient workflow.
Founder, Abundance Studio
More than 20 years as an advertising creative director, now focused on AI storytelling and directing.
Edit as you go to catch continuity errors, and get fresh eyes on your work.
Creative Lead & AI Facilitator, Superside
Formerly Creative Director & AI Ambassador at Monks.
Stop following trends, find your own voice and challenge clients.
AI artist, art director and motion designer
Award-winning, based in Sydney, with more than 20 years in design and broadcast.
Test one variable at low resolution before spending credits on a full run.
Creative director and AI filmmaker
Co-founder of the animation studio Estúdio Pé Grande, and has led films since 2008.
What platforms need most: consistency and camera control.
Director Creative & Branding, Aaj TV
Builds brands and visual identities across television and digital, and is now exploring AI filmmaking.
Don’t focus on making it look AI-generated. Focus on making it feel authentic enough to sell.
Art director; creator of I’M A PROMPT magazine
More than 25 years across branding, photography, art direction, publishing and advertising.
The next step is not more models, but better control over the ones we already have.
Creative Director, GR8 Events
Over 20 years across advertising, branding, design and brand experiences.
Don’t confuse generating with creating. Start with an idea, not a prompt.
Producer, filmmaker, editor and colorist
Brazilian audiovisual producer and 3D character artist with more than 20 years in the industry.
Don’t rely on a single prompt to solve everything. Treat AI as part of a production pipeline.
CEO & Creative Director, GLOBALRUNWAY
Creative director working at the intersection of fashion, advertising and AI.
Technology alone doesn’t create a compelling visual story.
Founder, CAPP
Founder of an AI creative agency at 19, with work published in Ads of the World.
Focus on the idea and the story, and how it relates to the company, before anything is generated.
Filmmaker, Creative Director & Founder of La Ola Creative
Award-winning filmmaker and creative director exploring the intersection of cinematic storytelling, artificial intelligence and branded entertainment.
Think like a filmmaker, not a prompt engineer.
AI creative specialist for DTC brands
AI creative specialist for direct-to-consumer brands.
Be consistent.
AI designer and creative writer
The creative mind behind BennyArtWorld, across visual design, storytelling and AI education.
Experiment with different tools and ideas a lot, just for yourself.
AI filmmaker and creative technologist
Turning Ideas Into Visual Experiences.
Creating cinematic AI videos, product commercials and visual stories that bring brands to life.
Contributors are working AI ad and UGC makers recruited individually through their published work. Each completed the same written survey between 5 October and 3 November 2026: their #1, #2 and #3 platforms for ad work over the past three months, why, what platforms should improve, and one tip. Partner, creator and ambassador relationships were asked directly and are disclosed in aggregate. We publish vote totals only, never an individual's picks.
Scoring gives 3 points for a #1, 2 for a #2 and 1 for a #3. The "without partner votes" column removes, for each contributor, any vote for a platform they named a relationship with. Counts of themes in sections 04 and 05 are our reading of the written answers.
Appendix
Full biographies, in the contributors' own words, and the work they chose to share.
Chief Creative Officer & Executive Advisor | Ex-Meta | Architecting Scalable Creative Systems, Driving Agentic AI & Creative Excellence.
Selected work
Chief Creative Officer at nmatic.ai. Previously Executive Creative Director at BBDO, DDB, Lowe and Interone China. 4 1/2 years of GenAI and at least 10,000 hours. It’s a talent multiplier, joy maker, career booster.
Selected work
Fabs is an AI Creative Director who blends years of creative experience with a hands-on approach to AI. Working across ideas, imagery and video, she’s fluent in the latest tools, models and techniques, using AI to push creative possibilities further. But for her, the real magic is in the human taste, instinct and judgement that make the work culturally relevant, creatively exciting and right for every brand.
Selected work
Silvia is an AI Creative Director with 10 years of experience bridging creative direction and audiovisual production through hybrid GenAI pipelines for major brands. A Krea.ai Creative Partner Artist with two AI Design Awards 2025 Special Recognitions, she also teaches AI creative workflows at leading business and creative schools.
AI Lead & Senior Creative Producer at Grey Denmark, part of WPP.
Selected work
With over 20 years of experience as an advertising creative director, Matt Waller has spent his career developing ideas and telling stories for brands. Now working in generative AI, he has shifted his focus towards AI storytelling and directing, exploring new ways to bring original ideas to life.
Selected work
Creative, art director and explorer of the possibilities of generative AI. I’m obsessed with good stories and every pixel that makes them possible. Currently Creative Lead & AI Facilitator at Superside, after my time as Creative Director & AI Ambassador at Monks.
Selected work
Jodie Heenan is an award-winning AI artist, art director and motion designer based in Sydney, with over 20 years in design and broadcast.
Selected work
Felipe Galvão is a Brazilian Creative Director and AI filmmaker, working independently across advertising, animation and generative production. He co-founded Estúdio Pé Grande, an animation studio recognized for premium work in advertising, and since 2008 has led films that pair strong visual storytelling with technical craft.
Selected work
I’m a creative professional working at the intersection of storytelling, branding, and technology. As Director Creative & Branding at AAJ TV, I work on building brands, shaping visual identities, and bringing ideas to life across television and digital platforms. Lately, I’ve been exploring AI filmmaking and new ways to create stories that were once difficult to produce. For me, technology is just another tool. The real difference still comes from the idea, the craft, and how you tell the story.
Selected work
Arnaud Templier works where an image begins to become an idea. For more than 25 years, he has moved between branding and photography, art direction and publishing, advertising and AI, with the same obsession: avoiding the generic. Creator of I’M A PROMPT magazine, he advocates an approach to image-making where technology is never the subject. The subject is the eye.
Selected work
Alexandre Costeira is a Creative Director at GR8 Events, with over 20 years of experience across advertising, branding, design and brand experiences. A multidisciplinary creative and curious explorer of emerging technologies, he believes creativity is less about the tools we use and more about the ideas we bring to life. He sees AI as a powerful creative partner, one that can amplify human imagination, but should never replace curiosity, critical thinking or a good idea.
Selected work
Chris Bolt is a Brazilian audiovisual producer, filmmaker, editor, colorist, and 3D character artist with over 20 years of industry experience. He specializes in AI-driven filmmaking, creative direction, and visual storytelling, with award-winning projects recognized at international festivals.
Selected work
Creative Director working at the intersection of fashion, advertising and AI. CEO and Creative Director of GLOBALRUNWAY and Creative Director at accessAI.
Selected work
19, founder of CAPP, an AI creative agency, featured in the BFA (British Franchise Association) and had work published in Ads of the World. Just failing a lot and learning faster.
Selected work
Award-winning filmmaker and creative director exploring the intersection of cinematic storytelling, artificial intelligence and branded entertainment.
Selected work
AI Creative Specialist for DTC Brands.
Ayomide is a creative professional specializing in AI design, AI tutoring, and creative writing. As the creative mind behind BennyArtWorld, she applies her skills across visual design, storytelling, and AI education.
Turning Ideas Into Visual Experiences. Creating cinematic AI videos, product commercials and visual stories that bring brands to life.
The series continues
Until then, Issue 1 covers the studios making ad creative for brands, and the AI Filmmaking Platform Rankings cover the platforms filmmakers ship on.